1. 12:07 19th Feb 2012

    Notes: 111

    Reblogged from gailsimone

    Would You Rather…

    gailsimone:

    This is a hypothetical question, no judgments made, and honest answers appreciated.

    If you have a creative effort that is your dream—if you want to be a writer, an artist, a musician, an actor, whatever—would you rather have a small audience that absolutely understands and adores what you do deeply, and the fringe critical respect that that usually entails, or great commercial success, but no deeply moved audience and poor critical response?

    Think carefully.

    I’d rather be nine people’s favorite thing than a hundred people’s ninth favorite thing.

     
    1. caprido reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
      Small audience. I hope...this means twenty people at least, though. I don’t have
    2. bakafox reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
      tricky one, since I do both art that tells stories/means things,...also just “YAY PRETTY...
    3. orquideasyacacias reblogged this from fyeahlilbitoeverything and added:
      Entre mas gente te oiga mas posibilidad hay que alguien te escuche. Además, ¿Que mas chevere que hacer lo que amas y que...
    4. lucya said: It would be possible to have both, I think - a small core audience that understands the material and a larger audience who completely misses the point but still throws lots of money at you - everybody wins!
    5. fyeahlilbitoeverything reblogged this from x-beni-o2-x and added:
      Commercial success. I figure even if you’re not the greatest filmmaker or writer or painter or rocker, the larger your...
    6. x-beni-o2-x reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
      Hmmm. I would prefer...small audience. Despite my yearlong hiatus with my actual writing...
    7. indestructible-theory said: Small audience. I don’t want to be just another Michael Bay or whoever.
    8. utopiangem said: so long as I can make a living from it I’d go for the small audience.
    9. roxannameta said: Small audience who appreciates me and some critical respect; but deep down, I’ll always wish I had a lot of money TOO.
    10. leeatard said: If I could live paycheck to paycheck doing something that I feel is actually worthwhile, I don’t think I would mind at all. I’m barely scraping by as is balancing a full-time job with being a full-time film student,but I’m loving every minute of it.
    11. thealucinaut said: 100% the 1st option. That actually describes my dream life, (that & a family). I write every day, chasing that. I don’t want to be rich, I want my stories to really matter to someone. Maybe that’s naive or cliche, but it’s the truest thing I know.
    12. sexymounties said: Actually now that I think about it I don’t know if I believe in the first scenario other. At least not the “perfect understanding” part. As a young artist already not making money I’d be grateful for anyone to like my work at all really.
    13. voodoo-otter reblogged this from sephiramy and added:
      My fellow nerds have shown me time and again that fame brings entitlement issues. Not in the sense of getting a big...
    14. introvertedart said: That is a tough one….I think that I would have to pick respect over money. But its a really hard choice. Really hard.
    15. douglaswolk said: The small, adoring audience. I do what I do to connect with people; every time I succeed at that, it’s a victory. Paychecks are just paychecks.
    16. sephiramy reblogged this from closetextrovert and added:
      have commercial success and have comic and art work pay my bills in full,...it really is...
    17. zone-4 reblogged this from gordondym and added:
      Please post your answer on our Facebook page
    18. turhansbeycompany reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
      I’ll take the money, thanks. Look, either way, I’m creating the stuff I want, right? So I’ve got
    19. gordondym reblogged this from gailsimone
    20. closetextrovert reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
      You say think carefully but I go for having...small, devoted audience almost immediately....
    21. upperclass-kitkat reblogged this from cherrycolouredx and added:
      Though I wouldn’t make as much money,...work seriously, therefore I’d
    22. jenlikescomics said: Small but dedicated audience. Shallow commercial success would make me question why I was doing it — the art or the fame.
    23. cherrycolouredx reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
      I think the first. My dream...really, really brilliant writer on a comic where I get...
    24. jimmyfury reblogged this from iridania and added:
      That’s another thing I was going to mention but then forgot about completely… If I ever get around to trying to get my...
    25. gothampeasant reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
      Small audience. No contest. As...writer, I don’t...write to...
    26. duncanpr said: I’d rather the small audience that gets it. There’s a song from the musical [title of show] called “9 People’s Favorite Thing” that sums up my thoughts perfectly: youtube.com/watch?v…
    27. wildmanshedevil said: It’s a difficult one… a commercial audience, though likely to generate more money, is in my eyes not as valuable as a smaller one that understands and adores what you do. At the same time, you have to sort out a form of income… so perhaps that.
    28. barryallenvsm said: In my younger days I would have wanted the great commercial success…but I’m not so young now and think about things differently. Commercial success is fleeting and easily lost - I’ll take the small audience now, and the lasting respect it brings.
    29. iridania reblogged this from jimmyfury and added:
      I write for myself and for my characters, not for other people. So I would rather write what I think is right and not...
    30. countryboylife said: The mob, the great unwased, always, bread and circus, general acclaim, mass popularity. Democracy.
    31. notaluallen said: all my life i have had to be someone else to have things work for me, i live in the south and i have to pretend a lot of the time. i would rather have people that liked me for me.
    32. melancholywise reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
      Definitely the first. I don’t create things to get rich or famous (if I wanted that I wouldn’t
    33. hamburgerjack reblogged this from deliciouskaek
    34. durkinator27 reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
      going to sound like I’m trying to be all goody-goody nice person. But to be completely honest, my main goal in life...
    35. missabnormal said: The first one, because I would hate and feel terrible to be famous through my failures. I want people to appreciate my work and love it, not mock it and hate it. If the latter happens to me, then I would consider myself a failure and worthless.
    36. eddyscanr said: Large or small, I’d rather inspire passion.